Photo of wildflowers in soft focus, overlaid with handwritten-style text that reads 'protect your peace'. A banner at the bottom reads, 'Have you tried the new ChatGPT 4o image generator?' with branding for Chris Olson Designs. — *Have you tried the new ChatGPT 4o image generator?*

As a graphic designer constantly exploring emerging technologies, I recently tested OpenAI's latest innovation: ChatGPT 4o's image generation capabilities. The question on every designer's mind: Can AI truly replace creative professionals?

Spoiler alert: It’s incredibly impressive for concept work, but there are still some limitations.

What is ChatGPT 4o's Image Generator?

OpenAI's latest image generation tool represents a significant leap in artificial intelligence's creative potential. Unlike previous iterations, this version offers unprecedented flexibility and creative range.

Two dogs stare at humorous street signs. Signs include quirky rules like 'No howling during full moons – violators will be cuddled.' Text below promotes ChatGPT 4o’s precision text placement, branded by Chris Olson Designs. — *The new image generator by ChatGPT 4o offers precision text placement.*

ChatGPT 4o Strengths: Where AI Shines 🌟

Impressive Text Handling

One of the most notable improvements is text accuracy within generated images. Previous AI tools often struggled with legible, correctly placed text—a critical element in design work.

Two editorial-style visuals featured are an outdoor apparel ad concept and a solar panel infographic. The caption below highlights the ChatGPT 4o image generator's ability to adapt to different design styles. — *The two editorial-style visuals featured above highlight the ChatGPT 4o image generator's ability to adapt to different design styles.*

Rapid Prototyping

ChatGPT 4o excels at quick concept generation. What might take hours of brainstorming can now be explored in minutes. Designers can rapidly iterate through multiple visual ideas without extensive manual work.

Style Versatility

From photorealistic renderings to editorial layouts and cartoonish illustrations, the AI demonstrates remarkable adaptability. It can switch between design styles with conversational prompts.

Graphic promotes ChatGPT 4o with 2 images. An illustrated movie poster of a llama and owl and a second image of a flat-lay photo titled 'What’s In My Bag?' showing camera gear and accessories. Chris Olson Designs branding. — *ChatGPT 4o handles illustrated poster art and editorial photography with equal skill—refining layouts, fonts, and style with ease.*

Limitations: Where Human Creativity Prevails 🧠

Technical Constraints

Resolution Limitations: Best for conceptual work, not final production
Detail Complexity: Struggles with intricate design elements
Brand Precision: Inconsistent in replicating specific brand guidelines
Print Quality: Not yet suitable for high-end print materials

The Designer's Perspective

Can ChatGPT 4o replace a graphic designer? Absolutely not. However, it's an incredibly powerful tool that can:

Speed up brainstorming processes
Generate quick design concepts
Provide inspiration
Assist in rapid prototyping

Future Implications

As AI continues to evolve, designers who embrace these tools will have a significant advantage. The key is viewing AI as a collaborative partner, not a replacement.

How does the new ChatGpt 4o rank on the Key Criteria for Evaluating Image Generators

1. Image Quality

Strength: GPT-4o produces highly detailed and photorealistic images, surpassing earlier models like DALL-E 3. It excels in creating visually appealing outputs for digital use.
Limitation: The resolution is not yet ideal for high-quality print materials, making it more suitable for concept work than final production.

2. Realism

Strength: It handles photorealistic content exceptionally well, accurately mimicking real-world visuals and artistic styles.
Limitation: While realistic, some complex scenes may still lack the nuanced imperfections of human-crafted visuals.

3. Diversity and Creativity

Strength: GPT-4o generates a wide variety of images, from abstract art to realistic photos and detailed infographics. It also supports imaginative prompts like comic strips or stylized graphics.
Limitation: Its creativity relies heavily on the quality of user prompts, meaning less detailed prompts may yield generic results.

4. Prompt Understanding

Strength: The model interprets and executes complex prompts with high accuracy, ensuring coherence and alignment between objects and attributes (e.g., maintaining proper relationships between colors, shapes, and objects).
Limitation: Occasionally struggles with extremely intricate instructions or highly specific niche requests.

5. Consistency

Strength: GPT-4o can bind attributes for up to 15–20 objects in a single image, a significant improvement over earlier models that struggled with consistency beyond 5–8 objects.
Limitation: Across multiple generations of similar prompts, slight inconsistencies in details may still appear.

6. Resolution and Print Readiness

Strength: Great for digital platforms like social media or web use.
Limitation: The resolution is not sufficient for large-scale print materials or professional publishing needs.

7. Efficiency

Strength: While it "thinks" slightly longer than DALL-E 3, this additional processing time results in more accurate and detailed outputs.
Limitation: The added processing time could be a drawback for users requiring rapid results at scale.

Summary:

ChatGPT 4o's image generator shines in areas like realism, diversity, and prompt accuracy, making it an excellent tool for concept development, marketing visuals, and creative exploration. However, its resolution limitations mean it’s best suited for digital use rather than print-ready outputs.

Pro Tip: Treat AI image generators like a sophisticated sketch pad. They're excellent for initial concepts but require a designer's critical eye and refined skills to transform those concepts into professional, polished designs.

Want to Stay Ahead of Design Tech?

Subscribe to my newsletter below.